Davis McClendon was killed on 7 May 2023 in Greenwood, South Carolina. His body was discovered crushed between his own car and another vehicle in what was ruled an intentional act. The investigation led to the conviction of William “Bud” Ackerman Jr., the estranged husband of Meredith Haynie, who had been in a relationship with Davis at the time. The case gained national attention and was later featured on CBS’ 48 Hours, as well as multiple true crime podcasts and documentary series.
Freddie’s song, titled “You Never Loved Him,” aimed to shift the focus from how his father died to who he was in life. “Thank you for bringing that and for sharing your heart,” judge Carrie Underwood said through tears. Lionel Richie appeared speechless, and Luke Bryan praised McClendon’s “honest” delivery, calling him “a modern-day Paul Simon.”
The emotionally charged moment stood out in an episode that also featured Carnie Wilson’s daughter performing “Hold On” with a group and a brief return from former finalist Bo Bice. Still, it was McClendon’s tribute that provided the night’s most powerful storytelling.
The segment has sparked conversation online, with viewers praising McClendon’s courage and composure. As the competition continues, his performance is already being seen as a defining moment of the season.