Sindh has turned into paradise’: Asif takes sarcastic swipe at Bilawal

Federal ministers Khawaja Asif and Mustafa Kamal have criticised PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari over his remarks on the “system reset” and the creation of new provinces, with both questioning his position on the issues.

Addressing an event in Karachi on Tuesday, Bilawal said the country’s governance system had not collapsed but had instead been “made to collapse”.

He also opposed the creation of new provinces and reportedly warned of a bloodbath if the move was imposed by force.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said any proposed reset of the country’s political system required public support, while Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal renewed his call for smaller provinces, saying they were necessary to improve governance and public services.

Asif said politicians derived their strength from public opinion and that citizens could not be deprived of their fundamental right to have a say in the country’s political future.

He said the proposed system reset could be debated in parliament and through a public referendum, adding that seeking public opinion should not be portrayed as a backdoor route to political change.

Taking aim at the PPP’s performance in Sindh, where the party has been in power for 18 years, Asif made a sarcastic reference to the province’s governance and Karachi’s condition.

“Sindh has turned into paradise. The world admires the condition of Karachi,” he said,

He also reminded Bilawal that the PPP had been an ally of the PML-N in the federal government since 2022, questioning the party’s criticism of the very system in which it was a partner.

“The PPP has been a partner of the PML-N in the business of government since 2022. The profits are yours, and the losses are the PPP’s — or Pakistan’s.”

“He who claims equity must come with clean hands,’ he said, adding, “this is a centuries-old maxim of equity. Are your hands clean? Do you have the right to lecture or threaten?

Meanwhile, Kamal argued that creating smaller provinces was necessary to address governance challenges and improve public services.

He criticised the PPP’s performance in Sindh, citing shortages of clean drinking water, inadequate healthcare facilities, poor infrastructure and limited employment opportunities despite substantial financial allocations to the province.

He also stated that urban residents of Sindh were being denied their fair share of government jobs and accused the provincial government of failing to address their concerns.

Questioning opposition to the creation of new provinces, Kamal said Sindh could even be divided into 10 provinces if doing so improved governance.

Referring to the 1973 Constitution, he said it provided a mechanism for creating new provinces and argued that constitutional amendments could be introduced to meet changing needs.

Responding to Bilawal’s warning of possible bloodshed in Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas and Sukkur, Kamal held the PPP chairman responsible for any violence resulting from the move.

“Even if a single drop of blood is shed, Bilawal Bhutto will be responsible,” he said.

Kamal maintained that smaller provinces were essential for strengthening Pakistan and ensuring that administrative powers reached ordinary citizens.

Related posts